a

Insurance Companies

Claims & Payments Phone Numbers

Cincinnati Insurance Company

Indiana Farmers

Progressive

SafeCo

Claims/Payments: 800-332-3226
Website

Mutual Insurance Association of Southern Indiana

Travelers

Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance Company

National General

American Modern

ForemostSTAR

Berkley Assigned Risk Services

Berkshire Hathaway

Liberty Mutual

Everett Cash Mutual aka 1st Choice

Claims/Payments: 574-267-6183
Website

NCCI

First Insurance Funding Corp

First Comp

Claims/Payments: 888-500-3344
Website

Minnonite Mutual

Claims: 1-800-678-6885 (extension 120)
Website

State Auto

West Bend

Mutual of Omaha

Claims/Payments: 800-228-7104
Website

Principal

Claims/Payments: 800-247-4695
Website

CSI Life Insurance Company

United Health Care

Claims/Payments: 888-842-4571
Website

Anthem

Claims/Payments: 888-641-5224
Website

Assurant

Prudential

Claims: 1-800-944-8786 (policy numbers beginning with the letter "V") / 1-800-778-2255 (all other policy numbers)
Pay Online
Website

Contact Our Office

Contact us